Skip to main content
Menu
Being Arrested Is Nearly Twice As Deadly For African-Americans As Whites

Sandra Bland’s death last week in a Texas jail — police say she committed suicide, but her family and friends have disputed that — has provoked questions about how police treated her and how they treat other African-American women.

The investigation being conducted by the Texas Rangers and the FBI will help determine what happened to Bland specifically, but we can put her death in context with national statistics on deaths in custody and arrest-related deaths.1 The data includes demographic information, so we can see how it varies by race.

libresco-datalab-jaildeath-1

Among whites, African-Americans and Hispanics being held in local jails, African-Americans are the least likely to commit suicide.2 Instead, illnesses — and heart disease, in particular — are the most common causes of deaths for black inmates while in custody.3 White inmates are five times as likely to commit suicide in jail as blacks.

Although African-Americans are at a lower risk of death in local jails than whites overall (largely because of the higher rate of suicide among white inmates), they face a higher risk of arrest-related death specifically. Among every 100,000 black people who are arrested, 5.6 die, compared with only 3 of every 100,000 white arrestees.

libresco-datalab-jaildeath-2

African-American arrestees are at a considerably higher rate of arrest-related death by homicide than whites. Those homicides are overwhelmingly likely to be committed by law enforcement personnel, not other jail inmates.4 The U.S. Justice Department counted 2,958 arrest-related homicides between 2003 and 2009; 99 percent of those were committed by law enforcement.

The Justice Department notes in both its report on deaths in jail and on arrest-related deaths that its numbers are likely to underestimate the true rate of deaths, because of underreporting, but that they have more confidence in the relative rate of different causes of deaths.

Because of the attention that activists have brought to Bland’s case, her death is more likely to wind up accurately tabulated in future updates to the DOJ’s numbers. It’s harder to be sure about the approximately 1,000 other deaths in local jails that take place each year.

Footnotes

  1. These two categories overlap when arrest-related deaths take place in local jails.

  2. Jails are locally run and usually hold inmates for a short time before trial or sentencing. Prisons are run by states or the federal government and usually hold sentenced prisoners.

  3. Heart disease deaths may include deaths that were partially the result of strain during arrest or other confrontations while in custody, as well as deaths unrelated to incarceration.

  4. Homicides include both justifiable and criminal homicides.

Leah Libresco is a former news writer for FiveThirtyEight.

Comments