FiveThirtyEight
Sarah Frostenson Monica Potts Nathaniel Rakich Geoffrey Skelley

Tonight was another jam-packed primary night, with eight states voting: Colorado, Illinois, New York, Oklahoma and Utah hosted their primaries, Mississippi and South Carolina held runoff elections, and Nebraska hosted a special election that was a lot closer than we anticipated, although ABC News has projected that the Republican, Mike Flood, will win.

One of the big stories going into tonight, though, wasn’t former President Trump’s influence — it was just how much Democrats meddled in GOP races, elevating the candidacies of more extreme GOP candidates in the hopes that they’d be easier to defeat in the general election.

In the Illinois Republican gubernatorial primary, Democrats got their preferred candidate, as state Sen. Darren Bailey easily won. The thought was that Bailey, as the more conservative candidate in the race, would face a steep uphill battle against incumbent Democratic Gov. J.B. Pritzker, given Illinois’s blue hue. But Democrats might later regret having backed Bailey as much as they did.

In Colorado, meanwhile, this strategy didn’t pay off for Democrats. Neither state Rep. Ron Hanks in the GOP Senate primary nor businessman Greg Lopez in the GOP gubernatorial primary ultimately prevailed. Nor did Mesa County Clerk Tina Peters, who was arguably the highest-profile election denier running in Colorado. Peters was banned from managing the elections in her home county, but still sought the Republican nomination for secretary of state. (She lost handily to former Jefferson County Clerk Pam Anderson, who accepts the 2020 election result.)

On that note, some of the night’s biggest election deniers, like Peters, Hanks and Lopez, did not win their primaries, but by our count, 15 candidates who either denied or questioned the legitimacy of the 2020 election still won their Republican primaries tonight.

Finally, another big story going into tonight was the potential number of incumbents who could find themselves on the chopping block. For instance, there were two incumbent-versus-incumbent battles in Illinois tonight thanks to redistricting, and in the Democratic-leaning 6th District, it was Democratic Rep. Sean Casten who ultimately prevailed, adding another loss to progressives’ record with Rep. Marie Newman’s defeat. (It should be noted, however, that progressives easily won in the new Illinois 3rd, an unexpected result, and their preferred candidate looks likely to prevail in Illinois’s 1st, as well.) Meanwhile in the Republican primary in Illinois’s 15th District, the Trump-backed Rep. Mary Miller handily defeated Rep. Rodney Davis.

It wasn’t just because of redistricting, though, that incumbents were in danger. Most notably in Mississippi’s runoffs, Rep. Michael Guest faced a strong challenge from Michael Cassidy, who launched a bid against Guest for his vote to create a commission to investigate the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol. Guest ultimately prevailed tonight, but the same cannot be said of Rep. Steven Palazzo, who had been embroiled in scandal. Palazzo lost to Jackson County Sheriff Mike Ezell.

Here are a few other key races we were watching tonight that have not yet been called:

  • In Oklahoma’s 2nd District Republican primary, we have most of the votes, but things are still too close to make a final projection about which two candidates will advance to an August runoff from this extremely crowded race. State Rep. Avery Frix leads with nearly 15 percent, followed by former state Sen. Josh Brecheen with about 14 percent and Muskogee Police Chief Johnny Teehee with 13 percent.
  • In Illinois’s 7th District, incumbent Rep. Danny Davis was fending off a challenge from Kina Collins, who positioned herself as the more progressive candidate. But the race was close: With 71 percent of the expected vote reporting, Davis was leading Collins, 52 percent to 46 percent.
  • The race was much closer in Illinois’s 11th District Republican primary, where former Trump administration official Catalina Lauf had about 29 percent of the vote, barely leading a crowded field of six total candidates, with about half of the vote in. The winner of the primary will aim to unseat the Democratic incumbent, Rep. Bill Foster.
  • Finally, the Republican primaries in Illinois’s 13th and 14 Districts remain too close to call. The race in the 13th is especially close, with nonprofit president Regan Deering slightly ahead of former federal prosecutor Jesse Reising, 35 percent to 33 percent, with 60 percent of the expected vote counted. Whoever wins will face former Biden administration staffer Nikki Budzinski in the general election. Meanwhile in the 14th, Kendall County Board Chair Scott Gryder has more of a sizable lead over Kendall County GOP Chair Jim Marter, 31 percent to 24 percent, with 74 percent of the expected vote in.
Nathaniel Rakich

Here’s one last look at how all the election deniers and questioners on today’s ballots fared.
How Big Lie supporters are doing tonight

Senate, House, gubernatorial, attorney general and secretary of state candidates who have either denied or questioned the legitimacy of the 2020 election, and their results in Republican primaries in Colorado, Illinois, New York, Oklahoma and Utah, as of 11:17 p.m. Eastern

CANDIDATE OFFICE Big Lie Position % REPORTING VOTE SHARE STATUS
Ron Hanks CO Sen. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 82% 44.8% ✗ Lost
Greg Lopez CO Gov. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 82 46.7 ✗ Lost
Tina Peters CO SoS 🚫 Denied legitimacy 81 27.0 ✗ Lost
Jennifer Qualteri CO-01 🚫 Denied legitimacy 40 100.0 ✓ Won
Lauren Boebert* CO-03 🚫 Denied legitimacy 99 64.4 ✓ Won
Ken Buck* CO-04 ❓Raised doubts 91 74.8 ✓ Won
Robert Lewis CO-04 ❓Raised doubts 91 25.2 ✗ Lost
Doug Lamborn* CO-05 🚫 Denied legitimacy 83 49.7 ✓ Won
Dave Williams CO-05 ❓Raised doubts 83 31.6 ✗ Lost
Rebecca Keltie CO-05 ❓Raised doubts 83 12.6 ✗ Lost
Erik Aadland CO-07 🚫 Denied legitimacy 88 47.9 ✓ Won
Laurel Imer CO-07 🚫 Denied legitimacy 88 15.7 ✗ Lost
Lori A. Saine CO-08 ❓Raised doubts 59 19.9 ✗ Lost
Peggy Hubbard IL Sen. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 71 24.1 Trailing
Matthew “Matt” Dubiel IL Sen. ❓Raised doubts 71 12.7 Trailing
Robert “Bobby” Piton IL Sen. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 71 9.1 Trailing
Jimmy Lee Tillman II IL Sen. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 71 5.0 Trailing
Darren Bailey IL Gov. ❓Raised doubts 80 55.0 ✓ Won
Gary Rabine IL Gov. ❓Raised doubts 80 6.1 ✗ Lost
David Shestokas IL AG ❓Raised doubts 69 21.4 ✗ Lost
Eric Carlson IL-01 ❓Raised doubts 68 40.6 Leading
Geno Young IL-01 🚫 Denied legitimacy 68 14.5 Trailing
Ashley Ramos IL-02 🚫 Denied legitimacy 54 27.8 Trailing
Niki Conforti IL-06 ❓Raised doubts 77 11.5 Trailing
Scott R. Kaspar IL-06 ❓Raised doubts 77 6.9 Trailing
Robert “Rob” Cruz IL-06 ❓Raised doubts 77 5.8 Trailing
Chad Koppie IL-08 🚫 Denied legitimacy 60 13.2 Trailing
Catalina Lauf IL-11 ❓Raised doubts 56 28.9 Leading
Mark Joseph Carroll IL-11 ❓Raised doubts 56 21.1 Trailing
Susan L. Hathaway-Altman IL-11 ❓Raised doubts 56 12.3 Trailing
Mike Bost* IL-12 🚫 Denied legitimacy 4 100.0 ✓ Won
Terry Martin IL-13 ❓Raised doubts 56 8.6 Trailing
James T. “Jim” Marter IL-14 🚫 Denied legitimacy 74 24.0 Trailing
Jack Lombardi II IL-14 🚫 Denied legitimacy 74 14.2 Trailing
Jaime Milton IL-14 🚫 Denied legitimacy 74 10.2 Trailing
Mary Miller* IL-15 🚫 Denied legitimacy 99 57.6 ✓ Won
Darin LaHood* IL-16 ❓Raised doubts 76 66.3 ✓ Won
Michael Rebresh IL-16 🚫 Denied legitimacy 76 8.2 ✗ Lost
Lee Zeldin NY Gov. ❓Raised doubts 44 43.6 ✓ Won
Andrew Giuliani NY Gov. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 44 23.0 ✗ Lost
Markwayne Mullin OK Sen. (special) 🚫 Denied legitimacy 96 43.8 Leading
Jackson Lahmeyer OK Sen. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 96 26.4 ✗ Lost
T.W. Shannon OK Sen. (special) 🚫 Denied legitimacy 96 17.4 Trailing
Nathan Dahm OK Sen. (special) 🚫 Denied legitimacy 96 12.0 Trailing
Luke Holland OK Sen. (special) ❓Raised doubts 96 11.2 Trailing
Joan Farr OK Sen. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 96 5.8 ✗ Lost
Scott Pruitt OK Sen. (special) 🚫 Denied legitimacy 96 5.0 Trailing
Adam Holley OK Sen. (special) 🚫 Denied legitimacy 96 0.5 Trailing
Mark Sherwood OK Gov. 🚫 Denied legitimacy 97 13.3 ✗ Lost
Avery Frix OK-02 🚫 Denied legitimacy 87 14.7 Leading
Johnny Teehee OK-02 ❓Raised doubts 87 13.0 Trailing
John Bennett OK-02 🚫 Denied legitimacy 87 11.3 Trailing
Wes Nofire OK-02 🚫 Denied legitimacy 87 6.3 Trailing
David Derby OK-02 🚫 Denied legitimacy 87 5.5 Trailing
Dustin Roberts OK-02 🚫 Denied legitimacy 87 4.9 Trailing
Pamela Gordon OK-02 🚫 Denied legitimacy 87 3.0 Trailing
Frank D. Lucas* OK-03 🚫 Denied legitimacy 59 61.1 ✓ Won
Wade Burleson OK-03 ❓Raised doubts 59 30.6 ✗ Lost
Tom Cole* OK-04 🚫 Denied legitimacy 64 69.8 ✓ Won
James Taylor OK-04 🚫 Denied legitimacy 64 27.0 ✗ Lost
Stephanie Bice* OK-05 🚫 Denied legitimacy 59 68.3 ✓ Won
Chris Stewart* UT-02 🚫 Denied legitimacy 84 72.1 ✓ Won
Burgess Owens* UT-04 🚫 Denied legitimacy 56 60.4 ✓ Won

*Incumbent.

Candidates marked as having “denied legitimacy” of the 2020 election either explicitly said Donald Trump’s loss or the 2020 election itself was illegitimate or, if an elected official, took legal measures to try and overturn the election. Candidates marked as “raised doubts” have questioned the fairness of the 2020 election or made references to “election integrity” but have not explicitly said the election or Trump’s loss was illegitimate.

Sources: News reports, campaigns, ABC News

Nathaniel Rakich

The Associated Press has called the Democratic primary in Illinois’s 17th District for Eric Sorensen. The former meteorologist is hoping for a sunny outlook in the general election against Republican Esther Joy King, but he’ll be facing heavy headwinds in this Republican-leaning national environment.


Exit mobile version