Updated 7:13 PM | Oct. 28, 2015CNBC Undercard Republican Debate: Live CoverageBy FiveThirtyEightFiled under 2016 Election Farai Chideya 6:56 pm Re: Jindal responding to a question about his minimum tax proposal even on lower-income Americans: The “47 percent” of Americans who paid no income taxes circa 2012 — a comment that helped torpedo Mitt Romney’s trajectory — is now 45 percent. × The best of FiveThirtyEight, delivered to you. Thanks for subscribing!You should receive a confirmation in your inbox shortly. Error: {{data}}. Email Address Morning Distribution (Daily) Your daily briefing from FiveThirtyEight. Top Stories Newsletter (Weekly) FiveThirtyEight’s top stories last week. Politics Newsletter (Weekly) FiveThirtyEight’s top politics stories last week. Popular Stories How Bad Could A Government Default Get? The Rise, Fall And Potential Resurrection Of Ron DeSantis Over 100 Anti-LGBTQ+ Laws Passed In The Last Five Years — Half Of Them This Year