HBO wrapped up its fourth season of the smash hit “Game of Thrones” on Sunday. The show is based on the bestselling “A Song of Ice And Fire” series, written by George R. R. Martin, who’s completed five of the series’ seven books. When the remaining two books will come out is a major source of stress and enthusiasm for fans, as well as a constant subject of speculation.
Martin’s novels can approach over 400,000 words and 1,000 pages in length — these are no small undertakings. And after he spent the first decade of the 2000s struggling to produce the most recent two books in the series, some fans have wrestled with the idea that Martin may not be able to finish writing the next two before he’s overtaken by the hit HBO show.
As a result, “Martinology” — the pseudoscientific process by which fans attempt to predict the release date for the forthcoming “The Winds of Winter” (“TWOW”), the sixth book in the series – has never been a more popular avenue of amateur study. A vast number of predicted release dates already have flown aerodynamically by. But there are a handful of entirely reasonable approaches some fans have used to infer when “TWOW” will come out.
In August 2013, one reader used back-of-the-envelope math to estimate an April 2014 release date for “TWOW,” based on assumptions about Martin’s progress, the rate at which he writes and the expected length of the book.
Perhaps the most encouraging analysis comes from another reader, who did some sleuthing and deduced from a gap between August 2014 and May 2015 in Martin’s rarely empty appearance schedule that the writer may have some plans to publish in the spring or summer of 2015. This seven-month gap is consistent with another in Martin’s schedule from November 2010 to June 2011, when the fifth book in the series, “A Dance With Dragons,” was formally announced.
Indeed, fans have also observed from Martin’s LiveJournal blog that the writer has been spending the past several months camped out at his home in Santa Fe, New Mexico, the only place where he is known to write.
So there’s a lot of speculation, but not many of these predictions are based on data. Can we use data to figure out how old George is doing? It can’t hurt to try. So here’s my stab at the prediction game.
We have quite a bit of data on Martin’s moods over the past decade or so, as he tells fans how he’s feeling at the bottom of each post in his regularly updated LiveJournal. And any dedicated reader of Martin’s blog knows that each year from August to December the man transforms from the nation’s preeminent living fantasy writer into that uncle at Thanksgiving who has everything riding on the performance of a football team. Or two teams in the case of this Bayonne, New Jersey, native: the New York Jets and the New York Giants. He even lost a bet and wrote a coded reference to the New York Giants beating the Dallas Cowboys into his fifth book in the series, as an Easter egg.
I decided to read the tea leaves by pulling Martin’s stated moods, as well as the performance of these two football teams, to see if there was any correlation between his publication rate and how he’s feeling, or how Big Blue and Gang Green are doing on the gridiron.
First, let’s look at what we know about Martin’s writing and publication rate. Martin, who’s 65, is a prolific writer. He publishes a series of novellas set in Westeros, where “Games of Thrones” also takes place. He writes an episode of the HBO series each season, he consults on other writers’ works that are set in his universe — such as “The World of Ice And Fire” encyclopedia — and he regularly edits anthologies, in particular his “Wild Cards” series. And that’s on top of the “A Song of Ice And Fire” series, the books of which I’ve listed below in order of publication.1
As for his progress on the forthcoming book in the series, according to sources compiled by a fan community, Martin anticipates “TWOW” will be about 1,500 manuscript pages.2 In October 2012, Martin told a reporter that he had written about 400 pages, but he hasn’t commented on his progress since.
Even more exciting is that Martin uses the advanced LiveJournal “Current Mood” technology to update fans on how he’s feeling. In the chart below, I’ve listed the top 15 moods Martin has tagged on his more than 1,400 blog entries,3 with the percentage of mood-tagged posts in the order they appear. I also looked at how Martin’s stated moods differed from his baseline mood rate in the 100 posts leading up to his announcement of completing “A Dance With Dragons.” I did the same for his most recent 100 posts. Here’s what I found:
It’s no surprise that Martin is often excited, pleased, happy and cheerful, as he’s enjoying the highest popularity ever and a smash-hit screen adaptation of his life’s finest work. But you’ll notice that he’s recently been twice as “excited” as usual. I mean, it’s not like the Giants made it to the Super Bowl or anything. Sure, the HBO show has been on the air, but about half of his most recent 100 posts pre-date the current season. What could Martin possibly be so excited about? Another big deviation from his norm is the sky-high numbers for “amused.” Hmm.4
As a fan, the fact that Martin is often “busy” is encouraging. But (and this is a big but) the lower busyness rate recently — 5 percent as opposed to his usual 10 percent, or his 11 percent right before the publication of his last book — is disconcerting. The optimist in me says that means the stuff he’s doing these days feels less like a chore. Towards the tail end of his last book, “A Dance With Dragons,” which was the culmination of a 10-year struggle to get words on paper, he was regularly “busy” but less often “pleased” or “happy.” He regularly referred to the book as “Kong,” a gigantic monster that had upended everything in his life. When he announced its completion, he said that he had killed Kong. Maybe “TWOW” isn’t another Kong.
Fans have speculated that Martin bit off more than he could chew with his many projects. Over the past several months, he has scaled back his commitments. Maybe that’s why he’s less busy? The pessimist in me, on the other hand, wonders whether he’s just not spending much time on the book.
There are no deep insights here into the timing of the “The Winds of Winter,” but it’s always nice to know that your favorite author is doing well, right?
Next we should turn to football, an interest of Martin’s that may have an effect on his mojo. Of the 1,410 posts we scraped from his blog, 121 — or 8.5 percent — were tagged with “NFL.” But before we look at the teams’ performances, we first have to try to quantify how fast Martin writes — or his words-per-day rate for each book — so that we can see how and whether Big Blue and Gang Green affect this rate at all.5
For the books where Martin had a cohesive plan in place — “A Clash of Kings” and “A Storm of Swords” — he wrote 392 final words per day and 673 final words per day, respectively. For books where he was building his world or untangling a hump in writing — “A Game of Thrones,” “A Feast For Crows” and “A Dance With Dragons” — he wrote at a substantially slower pace, at 145, 158 and 201 final words per day each.
The table at left takes possible average words per day figures and extrapolates how long it should take Martin to write “The Winds of Winter.” The values highlighted in gray show the rates at which Martin wrote “A Clash of Kings,” “A Dance With Dragons” and “A Feast For Crows.”
I also plotted the yearly performance of the New York Jets and the New York Giants against the words per day Martin was clocking during each season since 1991. The R-squared, which says how much Martin’s writing rate is explained by the teams’ performance, is laughably close to zero for both the Giants and the Jets. But if you’re a fan who needs something to believe in, I’ll tell you this: There’s a slight, if entirely coincidental, positive correlation between the Jets’ regular-season record and the words-per-day estimate:
So if you’re an exceedingly superstitious fan of the “A Song of Ice And Fire” books, it can’t hurt to root for Gang Green this time around.
If anything, this has been an exercise in the limits of statistical analysis. Understanding what data can and cannot do is just as crucial as being literate in the stats. Sure, we can make inferences, but the only thing this really comes down to is a genial man in Santa Fe, a harried editor in New York and a legion of international fans salivating so hard they’re beginning to dehydrate.
When will George R. R. Martin come out with the next book? I have no idea. The stats tell us essentially nothing. The good news for fans is that he’s in Santa Fe with a pretty clear schedule. The worst news is that my most promising finding is that he’s excited. As always, when will George R.R. Martin release “The Winds of Winter”? Whenever he damn well pleases.
Current Mood: anxious.